3 myths of the challenger sale | Funnel Clarity

Perhaps no publication over the past seven or eight years has been as influential in the sales performance space as The Challenger Sale. Sadly, it has given rise to three myths that are detrimental to the pursuit of a high-performance sales team. It is important to understand these myths of The Challenger Sale and to avoid the traps that these myths create.

The 3 Myths of the Challenger Sale

  1. The Challenger Sale is a new approach
  2. Only Challengers can win
  3. You need to overhaul your messaging

Challenger Sale Myth #1: The Challenger Sale is a New Approach

First, the major contribution of the The Challenger Sale is the idea that it put language to important best practices that were already well established. The idea of creating value before the purchase decision is made is not a new discovery by the team at CEB. The idea of helping a prospect think more thoroughly about the outcome they seek has been established since the release of SPIN selling. Figuring out the decision criteria the buyer will use and the important differentiators that distinguish the options being considered have been essential to high performance sales for a long time. 

It is good news that The Challenger Sale brought these core concepts to the attention of a new generation of sellers. However, it generated a myth that goes against core principals of professional and ethical persuasion. Executing the best practices listed above does not mean simply announcing to a prospect that their ideas or conclusion are wrong. Telling a prospect directly that their thinking is incorrect will often only get them to be more adamant about their views, even if those views are not accurate.

Funnel Clarity's sales training teaches these two rules that govern the execution of cooperative, ethical persuasion:

Rule 1: Customers/prospects put a higher value on what they say and the conclusions they draw than they do on what a seller tells them.

Rule 2: Customers/prospects put a higher value on what they ask for than they do on what is freely offered.

These are long held truths in the world of sales performance improvement. Therefore, a seller who freely shares what they believe to be true, and/or freely offers their opinion, demonstration, proposal, etc., is violating these principles. That will work against the interests of both the customer and sales person.

Challenger Sale Myth #2: Only Challengers Can Win

The second myth that people seem to hold is that The Challenger Sale states that only Challengers can win. The material in reality however, emphasizes that the seller needs to serve as an advisor or counselor. As an example, understanding what the customer is addressing and how they envision/define success is an important first step.  The techniques of doing so can be learned and employed by any of the seller types that The Challenger Sale defines. Challenging through inquiry is the key - the personality of the seller is not so relevant.

Challenger Sale Myth #3: You Need to Overhaul Your Messaging

The third myth of The Challenger Sale is that while aligning the organization as a whole around the sales strategy and approach has unarguable benefits, great progress can be made without entirely re-doing marketing messages or value proposition. The Challenger Sale advocates for this level of overhaul. Sales performance can be significantly improved without the need for restructuring the entire company’s operation.

Final Thoughts on The Challenger Sale

The Challenger Sale is a big topic and often one of controversy. Companies that have invested in the effort to implement the ideas in The Challenger Sale are clearly committed to believing. The truth is that “believing is seeing”.  If you believe that The Challenger Sale approach is the right move, you probably want to see it be effective. Take a step back and ask yourself with objectivity, is The Challenger Sale approach working for my team or do I want to believe it’s working?